Best Betty Crocker Toasters

Our review process

No more pouring over confusing infographics to try to decide which Betty Crocker toaster you need! By reading this article, you'll have an excellent grasp on what types of toasters are on the market, so you can confidently purchase a toaster to ensure that your food is toasted to perfection.

Our Top Ranking Toasters:
Our Top Ranking Toasters
Customer Rating
2 slices
Customer Rating
4 slices
Best Overall Score
An image of Betty Crocker BC-1618C Stainless Steel 2-Slice Silver 7-Mode Wide Slot Toaster

Choose the Betty Crocker Stainless Steel Silver 2-Slice Toaster to warm and cook your food to perfection. This toaster features an extra-lift lever, making it simple to get small items out and check on the progress of your food. It features auto-adjusting bread guides, extra wide slots, and LED backlit buttons for easy operation. This toaster is made with a cancel button and it has a bagel setting and a defrost function. It has a silver design, which is a beautiful neutral color that is easy to match with other appliances. It is perfect for toasting waffles, bagels, and different kinds of bread.

    • Stainless steel build is an attractive and extremely durable option
    • Silver hue is a neutral color that will always be in fashion
    • Extra wide slots can accommodate bread of all sizes
    • Stainless steel construction shows every smudge and fingerprint
    • Silver hue won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Two-slice capacity might take more time to toast your bread
Runner Up
An image of Betty Crocker 2-Slice Black Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster

Cook tasty, toasted food with the Betty Crocker Black 2-Slice Cool Touch Toaster. This toaster has a cancel function, so it can be shut down before finishing if necessary. It is constructed with an extra-lift lever and it is designed with cool touch housing, making it a great option if you have small kids running around, so they won't get burned. This black toaster has a sophisticated appearance that will look beautiful on any countertop. It can be used to toast bagels, muffins, and waffles. This toaster features extra wide slots, which can fit food of all sizes.

    • Two-slice capacity distributes heat evenly for ideal toasting results
    • Black hue gives your kitchen a contemporary look
    • Extra wide slots can fit food of all sizes
    • Black design might make your kitchen look darker than it is
    • Two-slice capacity is not a good choice for big families
    • Extra wide slots take a longer time to toast smaller food
Best for Families
An image of Betty Crocker Bc-2626cb 4-Slice Black Toaster

The Betty Crocker Black 4-Slice Toaster is a must-have appliance for your kitchen to make exceptionally delicious meals and snacks. This black toaster is an edgy and sleek choice that will look beautiful on your countertop. With dual independent toast controls, this toaster can accommodate multiple pieces of food at the same time while using different settings according to your preferences. It has two shade knobs, ensuring the ideal toasting temperature according to your taste.

    • Four-slice capacity lets you prepare more food at the same time
    • Black hue is great for industrial and modern style kitchens
    • Made with two shade adjusters for exact control of toast color
    • Black shade might make your kitchen look darker than it is
    • Four-slice capacity might produce uneven toasting
Understand More About Betty Crocker Toasters:
Capacity for a Betty Crocker Toaster
2-Slice Toasters

Want a toaster that can make exactly enough toast for your favorite breakfast? A 2-slice toaster could be perfect for you. We found two 2-slice Betty Crocker toasters on the market. Click here to check one out. 2-slice toasters distribute heat evenly, producing optimum results in less time. They will toast quickly, saving you time waiting for your food when you're hungry and ready to eat. They are typically designed with one or two slots to efficiently toast your bread. Typically designed with a single browning control button, 2-slice toasters limit the amount of control you have over how browned your bread will be. In addition, they aren't the best for large households, so if you're looking for a toaster for your family to use, you might want to consider something that can fit more food.

4-Slice Toasters

With only one 4-slice Betty Crocker toaster out there, you'll want to jump at the opportunity and have a look at it if you think it might be what you need. 4-slice toasters can toast multiple items simultaneously, so you can make food for many people by using the different slots at the same time. They typically have more browning controls than other toasters, giving you complete control over how crispy you want your toast. Something to consider is that they are a bit bulky, which will require more space. If you believe that a 4-slice toaster is perfect for you, why not check out this fantastic option.

Figure Out Which Color to Pick for Betty Crocker Toasters
Black Toasters

If you've been trying to find a black toaster, then check out some additional information below. Black toasters provide a bold contrast to your kitchen appliances, creating interest and drama on your countertops. They have neutral tones, which are a safe option since they are not as likely to go out of fashion than colored appliances. They have a minimalist design, which can be great for achieving a more polished kitchen design. If a black toaster is what you're looking for, then this may be a perfect fit for you.

Silver Toasters

If you're looking for a silver toaster, then check out some additional information below. With a metallic finish, silver toasters add a little bit of shine to your kitchen style. They have neutral tones, which will complement a variety of kitchen styles, from modern to rustic. They have a minimalist design, which can be great for achieving a more polished kitchen design. Think a silver toaster is what you want? Then why not have a look at this exciting choice.