Reviewing Classic Toasters


Our review process

Purchasing a new toaster is difficult, especially when you consider the endless amount of products available. With you in mind, we've already spent many hours gathering and analyzing information on more than 1,000 different toasters and also looked at the data points for each one. Out of these, we took another look at 40 classic toasters using our leading AI algorithm. The following article will cover the pros and cons and show you some of the more key information our research focused on, such as brand, color, and the exterior material.

We've reviewed classic toasters and wanted to share some information with you. Classic toasters feature a timeless look, making them a decorative appliance that will never go out of fashion. They offer turn-of-the-century inspired designs, adding visual interest to your countertops. They are traditional yet sleek with their trendy aesthetic and curved lines.

Our Top Ranking Toasters:
Product NameBrandMaterialCapacitySlot FeaturesDimensions
Best Overall Score
1
An image of Cuisinart Stainless Steel 2-Slice Classic 6-Mode Toaster
Cuisinart Stainless Steel 2-Slice Classic 6-Mode Toaster
Cuisinart
stainless steel
2 slices
Runner Up
2
An image of Russell Hobbs 850W Stainless Steel 2-Slice Classic Black 6-Mode Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster
Russell Hobbs 850W Stainless Steel 2-Slice Classic Black 6-Mode Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster
Russell Hobbs
stainless steel
2 slices
extra wide
6.7 in. x 9.8 in. x 7.9 in.
Durable Option
3
An image of VillaWare Stainless Steel Cinderella 2-Slice Classic 5-Mode Wide Slot Toaster
VillaWare Stainless Steel Cinderella 2-Slice Classic 5-Mode Wide Slot Toaster
VillaWare
stainless steel
2 slices
extra wide
12.3 in. x 8.3 in. x 7.6 in.
Best for Families
4
An image of Dualit Stainless Steel 4-Slice Classic Chrome Compact Wide Slot Toaster
Dualit Stainless Steel 4-Slice Classic Chrome Compact Wide Slot Toaster
Dualit
stainless steel
4 slices
extra wide
15.3 in. x 10.3 in. x 10.1 in.
For Artisinal Breads
5
An image of Cuisinart CPT-180W Stainless Steel 4-Slice Classic Silver 6-Mode Compact Wide Slot Toaster
Cuisinart CPT-180W Stainless Steel 4-Slice Classic Silver 6-Mode Compact Wide Slot Toaster
Cuisinart
stainless steel
4 slices
extra wide
11.2 in. x 12.5 in. x 8 in.
Our Top Ranking Toasters
Customer Rating
Brand
Cuisinart
Material
stainless steel
Capacity
2 slices
Slot Features
Dimensions
Customer Rating
Brand
Russell Hobbs
Material
stainless steel
Capacity
2 slices
Slot Features
extra wide
Dimensions
6.7 in. x 9.8 in. x 7.9 in.
Customer Rating
Brand
VillaWare
Material
stainless steel
Capacity
2 slices
Slot Features
extra wide
Dimensions
12.3 in. x 8.3 in. x 7.6 in.
Customer Rating
Brand
Dualit
Material
stainless steel
Capacity
4 slices
Slot Features
extra wide
Dimensions
15.3 in. x 10.3 in. x 10.1 in.
Customer Rating
Brand
Cuisinart
Material
stainless steel
Capacity
4 slices
Slot Features
extra wide
Dimensions
11.2 in. x 12.5 in. x 8 in.
Best Overall Score
An image of Cuisinart Stainless Steel 2-Slice Classic 6-Mode Toaster

Let's review the Cuisinart Stainless Steel Classic 2-Slice Toaster, a popular choice among online shoppers. This toaster features a removable crumb tray and cord storage, making clean up faster and easier than ever before. It features a defrost function, which automatically thaws your frozen food and then toasts it. This toaster has an extra-lift lever, making it easier to remove smaller items without burning yourself.

    Pros
    • Two-slice capacity distributes heat evenly for ideal toasting
    • Stainless steel build is a strong and corrosion-resistant choice
    • Removable crumb tray for convenient clean up
    Cons
    • Stainless steel build is generally a more costly choice
    • Two-slice capacity might take more time to toast your food
Runner Up
An image of Russell Hobbs 850W Stainless Steel 2-Slice Classic Black 6-Mode Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster

The Russell Hobbs Stainless Steel Classic Black 2-Slice Cool Touch Toaster is a must-have appliance for your kitchen to make exceptionally delicious snacks and meals. This black toaster is a sleek and edgy option that will look stunning on your countertop. Featuring a cool touch exterior, this toaster is great if you have small children running around, so they won't get burned if they accidentally bump into it. Built with a defrost function, it can cook food that came straight out of the freezer without having to wait for it to thaw first. It is made with extra wide slots and features a removable crumb tray, collecting any loose crumbs, debris, and dirt. This toaster can be used to toast buns and bagels.

    Pros
    • Two-slice capacity distributes heat evenly for ideal toasting
    • Stainless steel build is built to withstand years of wear and tear
    • Black design gives your kitchen an industrial feel
    Cons
    • Stainless steel build requires more cleaning
    • Black shade may make your kitchen look dull
    • Two-slice capacity is not a good choice for large families
Durable Option
An image of VillaWare Stainless Steel Cinderella 2-Slice Classic 5-Mode Wide Slot Toaster

If you're looking for a new toaster, you might want to consider the highly rated VillaWare Stainless Steel Classic Cinderella 2-Slice Toaster. Constructed of stainless steel, this toaster won't clash with your kitchen decor. It features a cancel function, which will manually end the toasting process. Featuring non-slip feet, it won't slide around your counter, ensuring safe operation. This toaster has two slots, which make it perfect for singles and couples. It has a removable crumb tray for convenient cleaning. This toaster has extra wide slots, which can accommodate bread of all sizes. It has five shade settings to choose from.

    Pros
    • Stainless steel construction will complement any decor from traditional to modern
    • Extra wide slots can fit bread of all sizes
    • Removable crumb tray makes it convenient to keep your toaster tidy
    Cons
    • Stainless steel construction requires more maintenance
    • Two-slice capacity might take more time to toast your bread
    • Two slots are not suitable for large households
Best for Families
An image of Dualit Stainless Steel 4-Slice Classic Chrome Compact Wide Slot Toaster

The Dualit Stainless Steel Classic Chrome 4-Slice Compact Toaster is a must-have appliance for any kitchen to make exceptionally delicious food. This chrome toaster is great for an elegant and modern appearance. This toaster features an extra-lift lever, making it easy to monitor and remove the items. It has extra wide slots and a removable crumb tray, eliminating any mess and saving you time with cleaning. Featuring a defrost function, it can toast food that came directly out of the freezer without having to wait for it to thaw first. This toaster can be used to toast buns, bagels, and grilled cheese sandwiches.

    Pros
    • Four slots can prepare four slices of bread at once
    • Can accommodate up to four slices of bread, making it great for big families
    • Stainless steel build will blend in your sophisticated and clean kitchen decor
    Cons
    • Stainless steel construction requires more maintenance
    • Chrome hue requires more cleaning since they will show any little stain or smudge
    • Compact design means it might not be as powerful as a bigger toaster
For Artisinal Breads
An image of Cuisinart CPT-180W Stainless Steel 4-Slice Classic Silver 6-Mode Compact Wide Slot Toaster

Make delicious, toasted food by using the Cuisinart Stainless Steel Classic Silver 4-Slice Compact Toaster. This toaster is designed with a cancel button and it features a reheat function and a bagel setting. It has an extra-lift lever, making it simple to regulate and remove the food. This silver toaster is a versatile choice that will complement all your existing kitchen appliances. It is designed with cord storage and it has a removable crumb tray and extra wide slots.

    Pros
    • Four slots can prepare up to four slices of bread at once
    • Can accommodate up to four slices of bread, making it perfect for big families
    • Stainless steel construction will match with everything
    Cons
    • Stainless steel construction is typically a more costly choice
    • Silver shade won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Compact design means it may not be as powerful as a bigger toaster
Best Safe Option
An image of Hamilton Beach 4-Slice Classic Chrome Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster

Use the Hamilton Beach Classic Chrome 4-Slice Toaster to warm and cook your food to perfection. This toaster has a defrost function, so you can cook food that came directly out of the freezer. Featuring a chrome hue, it is a chic option that will accent your kitchen with style. This cool touch toaster has automatic safety shut-off, which powers itself off if something gets stuck. It features extra wide slots to accommodate items of varying thickness from long artisanal breads to thick bagels.

    Pros
    • Four-slice capacity lets you toast more food at once
    • Chrome shade brings a sophisticated and contemporary appearance to your countertops
    • Extra wide slots can fit bread of all sizes
    Cons
    • Chrome design shows any little stain or smudge
    • Four-slice capacity is larger than 2-slice toasters and takes up more room
    • Extra wide slots take a longer time to toast smaller food
Additional Picks
An image of BLACK+DECKER Stainless Steel 2-Slice Classic Black 7-Mode Wide Slot Toaster

Cook incredibly tasty, toasted meals with help from the BLACK+DECKER Stainless Steel Classic Black 2-Slice Toaster. Featuring a defrost function, this toaster can cook food that came directly from the freezer without having to wait for it to thaw first. Designed in black, it has a modern appearance that will look beautiful on your countertop. It has an extra-lift lever for convenient regulating and removal of food. This toaster features extra wide slots, which can fit bread of all sizes. It is great for toasting bagels and buns.

    Pros
    • Two-slice capacity distributes heat evenly for ideal toasting
    • Stainless steel build can be used for years
    • Black hue makes it a sleek and edgy option
    Cons
    • Stainless steel construction requires more cleaning
    • Black hue can make your kitchen look dull
    • Two-slice capacity might take more time to toast your food
An image of Cuisinart CPT-180 Stainless Steel 4-Slice Classic Silver and Black 6-Mode Compact Wide Slot Toaster

The Cuisinart Stainless Steel Classic Silver and Black 4-Slice Compact Toaster is a much needed item for any kitchen to make exceptionally delicious meals and snacks. This toaster is built with a reheat function and it has a defrost function and dual independent toast controls. It is BPA free and features an extra-lift lever, making it simple to get small items out and check on the progress of your food. This silver and black toaster gives your countertop a sophisticated feel. It can be used to toast muffins and bagels. This wide slot toaster features cord storage and a removable crumb tray.

    Pros
    • Four slots can toast four slices of bread at the same time
    • Can hold up to four slices of bread, making it great for big families
    • Stainless steel build will go with everything
    Cons
    • Stainless steel build is generally a more costly option
    • Silver and black hue won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Compact design can't accommodate as much food as a larger toaster
An image of Cuisinart CPT-180MR Stainless Steel 4-Slice Classic Metallic Red Toaster

Highly rated by online consumers, the Cuisinart Stainless Steel Classic Metallic Red 4-Slice Toaster could be exactly what you need for your kitchen. This metallic red toaster is the perfect appliance if you want to add some life to your cooking area. This toaster is built with a defrost function and it features a reheat function and dual independent toast controls. It features two shade adjusters for precise control of toast color.

    Pros
    • Can accommodate up to four slices of bread, making it perfect for large families
    • Stainless steel construction will go with your existing appliances
    • Designed in metallic red for a vintage feel
    Cons
    • Stainless steel construction requires more maintenance
    • Metallic red shade is usually more expensive than white or black options
    • Four-slice capacity may produce uneven toasting
An image of Cuisinart 4-Slice Classic Black 7-Mode Compact Wide Slot Toaster

Use the Cuisinart Classic Black 4-Slice Compact Toaster to warm and cook your food to perfection. This toaster features a defrost function, which automatically adjusts the toasting time for frozen food. It features an extra-lift lever, which will raise the items higher out of the slots for easy retrieval. This black toaster is perfect for modern and industrial kitchen decors. It has extra wide slots, so it can fit all kinds of baked goods no matter how thick.

    Pros
    • Can hold up to four slices of bread, making it perfect for families
    • Black shade is a chic and edgy choice
    • Extra wide slots can accommodate bread of all sizes
    Cons
    • Black shade shows any dirt or spills
    • Compact design means it might not be as powerful as a bigger toaster
    • Four-slice capacity is bigger than 2-slice toasters and takes up more room
In the Market for a New Classic Toaster? Here Are Some Things to Know:
Capacity for a Classic Toaster
2-Slice Toasters

Looking for a toaster capable of making exactly enough toast for your favorite breakfast staple? A 2-slice toaster may be what you need. We found 20 2-slice classic toasters on the market. Click here to check one out. 2-slice toasters will toast quickly, saving you time waiting for your food when you're hungry and ready to eat. They distribute heat evenly, producing optimum results in less time. They are typically designed with one or two slots to efficiently toast your bread. However, they aren't the best for large households, so if you're looking for a toaster for your family to use, you might want to consider something that can hold more food. Typically designed with a single browning control button, 2-slice toasters limit the amount of control you have over how browned your bread will be.

4-Slice Toasters

If you're looking for a toaster that can handle your family's toasting demands, then a 4-slice toaster may be the ideal solution for you. We found 19 4-slice classic toasters on the market, so check out some what we discovered below. 4-slice toasters typically have more browning controls than other toasters, giving you total control over your food's level of crispiness. They can toast multiple slices simultaneously, saving you time when your family is rushing to get out the door. Something to consider is that they are a bit bulky, which will require more space. If you believe that a 4-slice toaster will satisfy your sandwich-making needs, take a look at this exciting product.

Pros and Cons of Different Materials for Classic Toasters
Stainless Steel Toasters

Looking for a stainless steel toaster that'll be right for your home? We will help you make up your mind by giving you some important information that you might want to know about. Resistant to corrosion, stainless steel toasters will remain in good shape over time. They are easy to clean, allowing you to simply wipe away any residue with a wet towel or cloth. They are usually insulated, helping maintain the internal temperature to facilitate fast and consistent toasting. With a heavy-duty build, they are ideal for everyday use. However, they will show any fingerprints, so they require frequent cleaning to keep them in good condition, especially if you have small children running around or will be using them everyday. Additionally, they get scratched easily, making them look older and dirtier than they actually are. Decided on which material is a good fit for your home? Then check out this great option.

Plastic Toasters

Looking to enhance your breakfast-making routine with a brand new toaster? Then why not have a look at this fantastic option. A cheaper option, plastic toasters are perfect if you're shopping on a budget. With a cool outer surface, they are a great alternative to metal toasters that tend to overheat. Easy to clean, they can be easily wiped down with a damp cloth or towel to get rid of any residue. Made of less durable materials, they will become less effective rather fast after purchasing.

Choosing a Color for Classic Toasters
White Toasters

If you've been looking for a white toaster, then check out some what we have to say below. White toasters provide a stark contrast to your kitchen appliances, creating drama and interest on your countertops. They have neutral hues, bringing brightness back into your kitchen while also giving it a clean and crisp look. They feature a minimalist design, which can help you achieve a clean kitchen design. Think a white toaster is what you want? Then take a look at this great product.

Blue Toasters

If you're looking for a blue toaster, then check out some additional information below. Blue toasters are designed with cool hues, giving your kitchen decor a refreshing feel. They are vibrant, adding some personality, charm, and character to your kitchen. They will add fresh tones to your kitchen. Think you may want a blue toaster? Then check out this exciting product.

Black Toasters

If you're looking for a toaster to complement your existing kitchen design, there are two black classic toasters available for you to choose from. You can have a look at one here. Black toasters provide a bold contrast to your kitchen design, creating drama and interest on your countertops. Featuring a minimalist design, they are ideal for achieving a sleek look among your kitchen accessories. Black toasters have neutral hues, giving them a modern and futuristic feel.