Reviewing Nostalgia Toasters


Our review process

No more reading through dozens of confusing articles to try to decide which Nostalgia toaster to get! By reading this guide, you'll have an excellent understanding of what types of toasters are available on the market, so you can confidently purchase a toaster to ensure that your food will always be delicious and perfectly crispy.

Before deciding on a Nostalgia toaster, let's talk about what makes Nostalgia unique. Founded in 2008, Nostalgia is a family run business. Nostalgia makes a range of products, which include kitchen appliances, popcorn makers, snow cone carts, and more. Its products are inspired by 19th century America, so they have an attention-grabbing design that surpasses the traditional standards of functionality and design.

Our Top Ranking Toasters:
Product NameSlot FeaturesDimensionsVoltageWeight
Best Overall Score
1
An image of Nostalgia 900W Blue Long Slot Toaster
Nostalgia 900W Blue Long Slot Toaster
extra long
10.8 in. x 6.9 in. x 7.7 in.
900 W
2.2 lbs
Runner Up
2
An image of Nostalgia Yellow 7-Mode Cool Touch Toaster
Nostalgia Yellow 7-Mode Cool Touch Toaster
10.8 in. x 6.6 in. x 7.7 in.
2.45 lbs
3
An image of Nostalgia 900W 2-Slice Long Slot Toaster
Nostalgia 900W 2-Slice Long Slot Toaster
extra long
11 in. x 6 in. x 7.8 in.
900 W
3.65 lbs
4
An image of Nostalgia 750W 2-Slice Long Slot Toaster
Nostalgia 750W 2-Slice Long Slot Toaster
extra long
750 W
Our Top Ranking Toasters
Customer Rating
Slot Features
extra long
Dimensions
10.8 in. x 6.9 in. x 7.7 in.
Voltage
900 W
Weight
2.2 lbs
Customer Rating
Slot Features
Dimensions
10.8 in. x 6.6 in. x 7.7 in.
Voltage
Weight
2.45 lbs
Customer Rating
Slot Features
extra long
Dimensions
11 in. x 6 in. x 7.8 in.
Voltage
900 W
Weight
3.65 lbs
Customer Rating
Slot Features
extra long
Dimensions
Voltage
750 W
Weight
Best Overall Score
An image of Nostalgia 900W Blue Long Slot Toaster

Make the most delicious meals with the Nostalgia Blue Toaster. This toaster is perfect for toasting muffins and bagels. It is blue, giving it a retro feel. Designed with a defrost function, this toaster can cook food that came straight out of the freezer without having to wait for it to thaw first. It features a removable crumb tray and cord storage, making clean up easier and faster than ever before.

    Pros
    • Blue design will adds some life to your cooking space
    • Removable crumb tray for convenient cleaning
    • Cord storage keeps your kitchen looking clutter-free and clean when not in use
    Cons
    • Blue hue quickly dates your toaster
    • Two slots are not ideal for large families
Runner Up
An image of Nostalgia Yellow 7-Mode Cool Touch Toaster

The Nostalgia Yellow Cool Touch Toaster is a much needed appliance for your kitchen to make exceptionally delicious meals and snacks. This yellow toaster is great for adding some visual interest and appeal to your countertops. This toaster has a defrost function, which will add the recommended time required to defrost and then toast the food. It has a cancel button to end the toasting process whenever you want. This cool touch toaster is perfect if you have small kids running around, so they won't get burned if they bump into it. With auto-adjusting bread guides, it produces even browning with every use. It is easy to clean, so your toaster will look and perform at its best. It features two removable crumb trays, which will keep your toaster and counters clean. It is perfect for toasting grilled cheese sandwiches. It has seven shade settings for you to choose from.

    Pros
    • Yellow shade is great for adding a hint of color to your cooking area
    • Two removable crumb trays collect any crumbs, debris, and dirt
    • Easy to clean for simple maintenance
    Cons
    • Yellow design can be difficult to match with existing appliances
Additional Picks
An image of Nostalgia 900W 2-Slice Long Slot Toaster

Use the Nostalgia 2-Slice Toaster to warm and cook your food to perfection. This toaster features a removable crumb tray and is designed with cord storage, making clean up easier and faster than ever before. Featuring a defrost function, it can toast food that came directly out of the freezer without having to wait for it to thaw first. It is great for toasting muffins and bagels.

    Pros
    • Removable crumb tray will catch crumbs and drips for convenient cleaning
    • Made with cord storage to keep your counters clean and free of unappealing wires
    • Defrost function adds the recommended time required to defrost and then toast the food
    Cons
    • Two-slice capacity might take more time to toast your food
    • Two slots are generally built with a single browning control button
An image of Nostalgia 750W 2-Slice Long Slot Toaster

The Nostalgia 2-Slice Toaster is a must-have appliance for any kitchen to make exceptionally delicious food. Featuring a defrost function, this toaster can cook food that came directly from the freezer without having to wait for it to thaw first. It features a removable crumb tray and cord storage, making clean up easier and faster than ever before. This toaster is great for toasting muffins and bagels.

    Pros
    • Designed with cord storage to keep your counters clean and free of annoying wires
    • Removable crumb tray catches drips and crumbs for convenient cleaning
    • Defrost function will save you time by thawing your food for you and then toasting it
    Cons
    • Two-slice capacity might take more time to toast your food
    • Two slots are generally built with a single browning control button
Need Help Narrowing Down Your Options? Here's Some Additional Information to Consider:
Decide Which Color to Pick for Nostalgia Toasters
Yellow Toasters

With just one yellow Nostalgia toaster available, you'll want to jump at the opportunity straight away. You can check it out here. With its cheerful shades, yellow toasters will liven up your kitchenware by adding a burst of color. They are vibrant, brightening up any dark or dull space.

Blue Toasters

If you've been searching for a blue toaster, then check out some additional information below. Designed with cool tones, blue toasters add color to your kitchen in an understated way. With a vibrant design, they look great in mid-century modern or eclectic homes. They will add a lively splash of color to your home. If a blue toaster is what you're looking for, then this might be the right fit for you.