Reviewing Plastic Toasters


Our review process

Purchasing a new toaster is no easy task, especially when you consider the numerous amount of products available. For your benefit, we've spent many hours gathering and analyzing information on over a thousand different toasters and also looked at the data parameters for each one. Out of these, we further reviewed 16 plastic toasters using our AI technology. The following article will discuss the advantages and disadvantages and show you some of the more key information our research focused on, such as style, color, and the number of slots it has.

Before you choose your new plastic toaster, we think there are some things you'll want to know. Plastic toasters are affordable, so you can pick a kitchen appliance that is inside of your desired price range. They are made to stay cool on the outer surface, so you are less likely to burn yourself while you are toasting your bread. Easy to clean, they can be simply wiped down with a wet cloth or towel to get rid of any residue. However, they have a more flimsy build, which will fade and lose their original color over time.

Our Top Ranking Toasters:
Product NameBrandCapacityDimensionsWeightColor
Best Overall Score
1
An image of Disney Plastic Mickey Mouse 2-Slice Red and Black 5-Mode Wide Slot Toaster
Disney Plastic Mickey Mouse 2-Slice Red and Black 5-Mode Wide Slot Toaster
Disney
2 slices
9.8 in. x 5.9 in. x 5.6 in.
2.1 lbs
Runner Up
2
An image of Uncanny Brands 680W Plastic Darth Vader 2-Slice Black Compact Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster
Uncanny Brands 680W Plastic Darth Vader 2-Slice Black Compact Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster
Uncanny Brands
2 slices
13 in. x 11 in. x 9 in.
2 lbs
black
Best Safe Option
3
An image of Cuisinart CPT-122 Plastic 2-Slice Black 7-Mode Compact Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster
Cuisinart CPT-122 Plastic 2-Slice Black 7-Mode Compact Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster
Cuisinart
2 slices
8.4 in. x 7.7 in. x 12.2 in.
2.6 lbs
black
For Artisinal Breads
4
An image of BLACK+DECKER TR2200WSD Plastic 2-Slice Modern White 7-Mode Compact Wide Slot Toaster
BLACK+DECKER TR2200WSD Plastic 2-Slice Modern White 7-Mode Compact Wide Slot Toaster
BLACK+DECKER
2 slices
7.8 in. x 11.8 in. x 9.4 in.
4.05 lbs
white
Best for Families
5
An image of Brentwood TS-264 Plastic 4-Slice White 6-Mode Toaster
Brentwood TS-264 Plastic 4-Slice White 6-Mode Toaster
Brentwood
4 slices
10.6 in. x 10.2 in. x 7.1 in.
3.2 lbs
white
Our Top Ranking Toasters
Customer Rating
Brand
Disney
Capacity
2 slices
Dimensions
9.8 in. x 5.9 in. x 5.6 in.
Weight
2.1 lbs
Color
Customer Rating
Brand
Uncanny Brands
Capacity
2 slices
Dimensions
13 in. x 11 in. x 9 in.
Weight
2 lbs
Color
black
Customer Rating
Brand
Cuisinart
Capacity
2 slices
Dimensions
8.4 in. x 7.7 in. x 12.2 in.
Weight
2.6 lbs
Color
black
Customer Rating
Brand
BLACK+DECKER
Capacity
2 slices
Dimensions
7.8 in. x 11.8 in. x 9.4 in.
Weight
4.05 lbs
Color
white
Customer Rating
Brand
Brentwood
Capacity
4 slices
Dimensions
10.6 in. x 10.2 in. x 7.1 in.
Weight
3.2 lbs
Color
white
Best Overall Score
An image of Disney Plastic Mickey Mouse 2-Slice Red and Black 5-Mode Wide Slot Toaster

Make exceptionally delicious, toasted meals with help from the Disney Plastic Mickey Mouse Red and Black 2-Slice Toaster. This wide slot toaster has a hinged crumb tray, decreasing any mess and saving you time with clean up. Designed with non-slip feet, this toaster won't scratch your countertops. This Mickey Mouse toaster leaves a Mickey icon imprint on your toast as it browns.

    Pros
    • Plastic construction is a strong yet lightweight option that will withstand daily use
    • Extra wide slots can fit food of all sizes
    • Hinged crumb tray collects any crumbs, debris, and dust
    Cons
    • Plastic build might contain harmful chemicals
    • Two-slice capacity may take more time to toast your food
    • Two slots are typically built with one browning control button
Runner Up
An image of Uncanny Brands 680W Plastic Darth Vader 2-Slice Black Compact Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster

The Uncanny Brands Plastic Darth Vader Black 2-Slice Cool Touch Compact Toaster is a much needed item for your kitchen to make exceptionally delicious food. This toaster is made with extra wide slots and it features a shade knob and a removable crumb tray. Featuring cool touch housing, it is perfect if you have small kids running around, so they won't get burned if they bump into it. Made with a defrost function, this toaster will turn frozen goods into hot and delicious food. This Darth Vader toaster is perfect for any Star Wars lover. It is great for toasting buns and hamburgers.

    Pros
    • Plastic construction is a strong yet lightweight choice that will withstand wear and tear
    • Black design makes it great for modern and industrial style kitchens
    • Extra wide slots can fit food of all sizes
    Cons
    • Plastic construction might contain dangerous chemicals
    • Black shade is more trendy than timeless and might go out of fashion
    • Compact design means it may not be as powerful as a larger toaster
Best Safe Option
An image of Cuisinart CPT-122 Plastic 2-Slice Black 7-Mode Compact Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster

Enhance your kitchen and cooking experience by using the functional Cuisinart Plastic Black 2-Slice Cool Touch Compact Toaster. This black toaster has a chic appearance that will look beautiful on your countertop. This toaster is designed with a defrost function and it has a bagel setting and a reheat function. This wide slot toaster features a slide open crumb tray and a space-saving design, making it excellent for small kitchens. It is designed with an extra-lift lever and it is made with a cool touch exterior, making it a perfect option if you have small children running around, so they won't get burned.

    Pros
    • Plastic build is a durable yet lightweight option that will withstand daily use
    • Black shade makes it great for industrial and modern style kitchens
    • Extra wide slots can fit food of all sizes
    Cons
    • Plastic construction is less durable than stainless steel
    • Black shade shows any dirt or spills
    • Compact design means it may not be as powerful as a bigger toaster
For Artisinal Breads
An image of BLACK+DECKER TR2200WSD Plastic 2-Slice Modern White 7-Mode Compact Wide Slot Toaster

Cook incredibly tasty, toasted food by using the BLACK+DECKER Plastic Modern White 2-Slice Compact Toaster. This toaster is made with a cancel button and it has a bagel setting and a defrost function. It has a white hue, which is the brightest and cleanest neutral color. This toaster has an extra-lift lever, making it simple to remove small items and check on the progress of your food. It is made with one touch auto lowering and it features extra wide slots and auto-adjusting bread guides. This toaster is great for toasting waffles and bagels.

    Pros
    • Plastic construction is a durable yet lightweight material that will withstand wear and tear
    • White design will add sophistication to your cooking area
    • Extra wide slots can accommodate food of all sizes
    Cons
    • Plastic build is not as safe as preparing food on stainless steel or metal
    • White shade won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Compact design means it might not be as powerful as a larger toaster
Best for Families
An image of Brentwood TS-264 Plastic 4-Slice White 6-Mode Toaster

The Brentwood Plastic White 4-Slice Toaster is a much needed item for your kitchen to make exceptionally delicious snacks and meals. This white toaster will give your countertop a clean, classic, and sophisticated appearance. Designed with two shade adjusters, this toaster will toast your food to the perfect amount of crispiness, depending on your personal preference. It has a cancel function, instantly stopping the toasting process if you decide you want to take your food out.

    Pros
    • Can hold up to four slices of bread, making it great for big families
    • Plastic build is a durable yet lightweight material that will withstand daily use
    • White hue goes with everything
    Cons
    • Plastic build is less durable than stainless steel
    • White hue won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Four-slice capacity may produce uneven toasting results
For Trendy Homes
An image of Sunbeam 1500W Plastic 4-Slice Modern White 7-Mode Wide Slot Toaster

If you're searching for a new toaster, you might want to consider the highly rated Sunbeam Plastic Modern White 4-Slice Toaster. This toaster has a bagel setting, dual independent toast controls, and a cancel function, so it can be shut down before finishing when necessary. It is designed with an extra-lift lever and it is made with an anti-jam feature, preventing food from getting stuck inside. Designed in white, it will blend in with any decor from traditional to modern. This wide slot toaster has an easy-to-clean design and a removable crumb tray.

    Pros
    • Four slots can prepare up to four slices of bread at the same time
    • Can hold up to four slices of bread, making it perfect for families
    • Plastic construction is a durable yet lightweight choice that will withstand wear and tear
    Cons
    • Plastic construction is not as durable as than stainless steel
    • White shade won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Four-slice capacity might produce uneven toasting results
Additional Picks
An image of Continental Electric Plastic 2-Slice White Cool Touch Toaster

Let's review the Continental Electric Plastic White 2-Slice Cool Touch Toaster, rated highly by online shoppers. This toaster has a shade selector knob, so you can select your desired shade for the perfect taste and texture. It features a cool touch exterior, so you don't have to worry about singeing your fingers. It features a cancel function, allowing you to end the process in case your food is toasting faster than expected. This white toaster is a versatile option that will blend in with your existing kitchen decor.

    Pros
    • Two-slice capacity distributes heat evenly for ideal toasting
    • Plastic construction is a strong yet lightweight material that will withstand wear and tear
    • White hue won't clash with your kitchen appliances
    Cons
    • Plastic build might contain dangerous chemicals
    • White design won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Two-slice capacity may take more time to toast your food
An image of Premium PT230B 750W Plastic 2-Slice Black Compact Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster

The Premium Plastic Black 2-Slice Compact Toaster is a much needed appliance for your kitchen to make exceptionally delicious meals and snacks. This cool touch toaster features an extra-lift lever and automatic safety shut-off, turning itself off if the contents get stuck inside. This toaster features extra wide slots, so it can accommodate all kinds of food no matter how thick, and a removable crumb tray for less mess and easy cleaning. It is designed with a cancel function to stop the toasting cycle whenever you want. This black toaster is a sleek and edgy option that will look stunning on your countertop. It is perfect for toasting bagels, waffles, and different types of bread.

    Pros
    • Plastic build is a strong yet lightweight material that will withstand wear and tear
    • Black design makes it ideal for modern and industrial style kitchens
    • Extra wide slots can accommodate food of all sizes
    Cons
    • Plastic build has a much shorter lifespan than metal
    • Black shade can make your kitchen look dark
    • Compact design means it may not be as powerful as a larger toaster
An image of Proctor Silex 24605 Plastic 4-Slice White Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster

Warm up and cook all your favorite meals with the Proctor Silex Plastic White 4-Slice Toaster. This toaster is great for toasting bagels and different kinds of bread. It has a white shade, which is the cleanest and brightest neutral color. This wide slot toaster features a slide open crumb tray and has automatic toast boost, allowing you to safely remove even the smallest content. Featuring automatic safety shut-off, this cool touch toaster will turn itself off if something gets stuck inside.

    Pros
    • Four slots can prepare up to four slices of bread at the same time
    • Can hold up to four slices of bread, making it perfect for families
    • Plastic construction is a durable yet lightweight choice that will withstand wear and tear
    Cons
    • Plastic construction has a much shorter lifespan than metal
    • White hue won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Four-slice capacity may produce uneven toasting results
An image of Premium PT230 Plastic 2-Slice Black 6-Mode Compact Cool Touch Wide Slot Toaster

The Premium Plastic Black 2-Slice Compact Toaster is a much needed appliance for any kitchen to make exceptionally toasted food. Featuring automatic safety shut-off, this cool touch toaster will turn itself off in case something gets stuck inside. This toaster has a removable crumb tray for less mess and easy cleaning, and extra wide slots, so it can accommodate all kinds of food no matter how thick. It is designed with a defrost function and it has a cancel button and a reheat function. This black toaster will add a chic and modern look to your countertops.

    Pros
    • Plastic build is a durable yet lightweight choice that will withstand daily use
    • Black hue makes it perfect for modern and industrial style kitchens
    • Extra wide slots can accommodate bread of all sizes
    Cons
    • Plastic build might contain dangerous chemicals
    • Black hue can make your kitchen look dark
    • Compact design means it might not be as powerful as a larger toaster
Plastic Toasters: Some Additional Information to Know:
Which Features Are Best for Your Plastic Toaster?
Long Slot Toasters

Trying to pick the most fitting extra long slot toaster for your kitchen? We'll help you make your choice by giving you the pros and cons. Because of their long slots, these toasters can accommodate nearly any size bread. They feature a narrow profile, so they will fit perfectly on your counter without taking up a lot of space. Long slot toasters can fit more than one slice of bread in each slot, so you will be able to make toast for the whole family in the morning before school and work. Ready to buy the right long toaster for your home? Get started with this plastic toaster.

Wide Slot Toasters

Trying to pick the most suitable extra wide slot toaster for you? We'll help you decide by providing you with some information that you need. Because of their wide slots, these toasters can accommodate nearly any size bread. They provide more slot room, preventing the bread from falling apart or getting stuck inside the toaster. However, the heating elements are located further apart than in toasters with standard slots, so your food may need more cooking time. Decided on the kind of slots that are right for you? Then check out this fantastic product.

Which Style Is the Best Fit for Your Plastic Toaster
Modern Toasters

Looking to purchase a new toaster to enhance your sandwich-making routine? We have only one modern toaster available. Click here to check it out now. With a minimalist design, these modern toasters will seamlessly blend with the rest of your kitchen accessories. They usually have more features than classic toasters, making them aesthetically pleasing and technologically advance appliances. They will look great with industrial, mid-century, and modern styles. They are typically stainless steel for glossy and appealing looks to any kitchen decor.

Classic Toasters

Looking to upgrade your breakfast-making routine with a new toaster? Then take a look at this fantastic option. Classic toasters provide turn-of-the-century inspired details, adding visual interest to your kitchen. They are the perfect balance of artistic flair and sleek style, making a stylish statement in your kitchen. With their timeless look, these classic toasters are a decorative appliance that will never go out of style.

How Many Slices of Bread Will Fit in These Plastic Toasters
2-Slice Toasters

Want a toaster that can make just enough toast for your favorite breakfast? A 2-slice toaster may be perfect for you. We found 12 2-slice plastic toasters that are available today. So have a look at this plastic toaster to get you started. 2-slice toasters will toast quickly, saving you time waiting for your food when you're hungry and ready to eat. They are typically built with one or two slots to efficiently toast your bread. They distribute heat evenly, producing the best toasting in less time. Typically made with one browning control button, they will prevent you from being able to control how browned your toast gets. On top of that, they aren't suitable for large households, so if you're looking for a toaster for your family to share, you might want to consider one that can accommodate more food.

4-Slice Toasters

If you're looking for a toaster that can handle your family's toasting demands, then a 4-slice toaster may be the ideal solution for you. We found three 4-slice plastic toasters that are available today, so keep reading below to learn more. Generally designed with more browning controls, these 4-slice toasters give you total control over how crispy you want your food. With increased toasting capacity, they save you precious time when you and your family are rushing to get out the door. One downside is that they are a bit bulky in size, taking up a lot of space on your countertops. If you think that a 4-slice toaster is what you need, take a look at this fantastic option.